When we have to resort to using hot rolled material the mill scale can be a real bitch to deal with. In a HOMEMADETOOLS.com blog dump a while ago a guy had a really easy way of removing mill scale with of all things vinegar.
Here is a link to the vid.
https://www.homemadetools.net/forum/sim ... post183664
Now it's not a quick method but it is easy, it just takes a little planning so you don't end up with a bunch of down time (if that's an issue).
I tried it out in my shop and I can say, it does work and it works well, you just have to soak your material for about 4-5 days for it to disolve all the scale.
Thought this was interesting and just wanted to share.
Removing mill scale
-
- Tourist
- Posts: 46
- Joined: Tue Jun 02, 2015 2:45 pm
- SELF INTRODUCTION: Have always liked choppers since I was a kid, never thought I had skills enough untill I found the "Handbook" sight just recently. Reading the info posted on the "Hand book" sight made me think maybe I can.
I have a little experience fabricating things.
Hoping the yahoo e-mail account doesn't disqualify me from being a member here. - Location: Oregon City, Oregon
Removing mill scale
I know the voices aren't real, but they do have some good ideas
- budoka
- Site Admin
- Posts: 492
- Joined: Thu Jul 21, 2011 12:51 pm
- SELF INTRODUCTION: I'm a Kentucky boy who's found himself transplanted into Japan. been into turning wrenches as long as i can remember. i love muscle cars, hotrod bikes, and the martial arts.
been a member of this board since back when it was a part of Chopperweb. been handling the tech side and sharing the admin duties for several years now. - Location: Fuefuki Shi, Japan
- Contact:
Re: Removing mill scale
hmmm, nice tip. i sure do hate mill scale.
-dan
-dan
-experience is a wonderful thing. It enables you to recognize a mistake when you make it again.
http://knuckleheadsummer.blogspot.com/
http://knuckleheadsummer.blogspot.com/
- railroad bob
- Contributor
- Posts: 939
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 10:07 pm
- SELF INTRODUCTION: Hi Dan, thanks for your time and energy spent on this new board. I hope you will give me a waiver on the email account, I have used gmail so long I don't have a clue what my service provider account is.
I just returned home from a 2 week trip in New Mexico, have a few good pix, can't wait to share my off-highway traveling. Got to put 1400 miles on the scoot.
Best, Bob Davidson - Location: Alaska
Re: Removing mill scale
I watched the video, interesting method, useful for projects with small pieces and pre-planning.
Being a welding inspector, I've seen considerable mill scale, and always considered it to be flaking on the surface.
I had to look a little farther, did a search on mill scale. Was surprised to see the blueish color is also scale.
And I found a site about it's impact on welding.
In short, the condition shown in the video is not much of a concern for welding except for TIG.
The gentleman who posted the video shows a grinding disc he uses to remove the scale, but others have more success with sanding discs. They come in various grits depending on how aggressive you need to be.
https://weldersmanual.com/mill-scale-sh ... remove-it/
Being a welding inspector, I've seen considerable mill scale, and always considered it to be flaking on the surface.
I had to look a little farther, did a search on mill scale. Was surprised to see the blueish color is also scale.
And I found a site about it's impact on welding.
In short, the condition shown in the video is not much of a concern for welding except for TIG.
The gentleman who posted the video shows a grinding disc he uses to remove the scale, but others have more success with sanding discs. They come in various grits depending on how aggressive you need to be.
https://weldersmanual.com/mill-scale-sh ... remove-it/
Alaska - Land of the Individual and Other Endangered Species
An Armed Society is a Polite Society,...
Politicians Prefer Unarmed Peasants
TANSTAAFL
An Armed Society is a Polite Society,...
Politicians Prefer Unarmed Peasants
TANSTAAFL
-
- Tourist
- Posts: 46
- Joined: Tue Jun 02, 2015 2:45 pm
- SELF INTRODUCTION: Have always liked choppers since I was a kid, never thought I had skills enough untill I found the "Handbook" sight just recently. Reading the info posted on the "Hand book" sight made me think maybe I can.
I have a little experience fabricating things.
Hoping the yahoo e-mail account doesn't disqualify me from being a member here. - Location: Oregon City, Oregon
Re: Removing mill scale
I was thinking more along the lines of removing the scale for making parts for forks and such. Soaking in vinegar for a few days is much easier than trying to sand/grind thru all that shit to get to actual steel. It also saves on sanding belts, grinding wheels, and elbow grease.
Also I figured out the hard way that if you soak your parts to be in some lacquer thinner or acetone to remove the oil and grease, the vinegar works better and lasts longer.
Also I figured out the hard way that if you soak your parts to be in some lacquer thinner or acetone to remove the oil and grease, the vinegar works better and lasts longer.
I know the voices aren't real, but they do have some good ideas
- railroad bob
- Contributor
- Posts: 939
- Joined: Fri Nov 04, 2011 10:07 pm
- SELF INTRODUCTION: Hi Dan, thanks for your time and energy spent on this new board. I hope you will give me a waiver on the email account, I have used gmail so long I don't have a clue what my service provider account is.
I just returned home from a 2 week trip in New Mexico, have a few good pix, can't wait to share my off-highway traveling. Got to put 1400 miles on the scoot.
Best, Bob Davidson - Location: Alaska
Re: Removing mill scale
Ah, more good ideas. Makes sense the vinegar wont cut the oil very well.Might not have to soak the parts, just a wipe down might do the trick. Maybe not have to use so much acetone/thinner.
But I can see having a dedicated container of thinner to put small stuff in, reuse it as needed.
But I can see having a dedicated container of thinner to put small stuff in, reuse it as needed.
Alaska - Land of the Individual and Other Endangered Species
An Armed Society is a Polite Society,...
Politicians Prefer Unarmed Peasants
TANSTAAFL
An Armed Society is a Polite Society,...
Politicians Prefer Unarmed Peasants
TANSTAAFL